Ted cook
Hickory Flooring Pros and Cons

a wide plank hickory floor in a penthouse

Hickory hardwood flooring is a popular and durable choice for flooring. You'll find its mentioned as a charming rustic hardwood and that it will most likely last for decades. Many decor professionals will recommend hickory, but I can help you understand the  hickory flooring pros and cons you need to juggle. There is a creamy brown heartwood that will add a ton of contrast to a piece of lighter sapwood in the same board!

This is what drives the aesthetic appeal for hickory, and for some, it's hard to resist. Read below to learn why hickory is loved and hated in the US.

Table Of Contents:

  • Understanding Hickory Wood
  • Pros of Hickory Flooring
    • Enhances Home Resale Values
      • Bonus Point:Looks Great and Scratch-Resistant
      • Cons of Hickory Floors
      • Compared to Other Wood Options
      • Solid vs. Engineered
      • FAQs

        Understanding Hickory Wood

        Hickory wood is harvested from trees native in North America and Asia. It is globally renowned for its strength and density, stemming from its dominating hardess score. It boasts a score of 1820 on the Janka hardness scale, making it more than 30% stronger than white oak and even tougher than red oak. There are only a few exotic woods that are more dense than hickory, so spending thousands more for an import is not a cost effective solution in my eyes when it comes to 

        man installing hickory wood floors

        The Properties of Hickory Wood

        This robust nature can be attributed to hickory's unique grain patterns. The distinctiveness in its grains not only contributes to aesthetic appeal but also plays a significant role in enhancing its toughness. Hence, if you're seeking durable flooring options, then ReallyCheapFloors.com offers - your search with the best deals on hickory hardwood. Apart from being hardy and resilient against wear-and-tear, another advantage this species holds is variety. You see various types within this genus; each differs slightly by appearance or characteristics giving homeowners plenty of choices when picking their perfect floor. If you ever get confused about identifying genuine hickories among these variants – don't fret. A quick visit to Hickory Tree Identification should clear things up for you.

      • American Home Hickory Natural Hardwood
      •  

        Harnessing Hickroy's Strength For Your Floors

        Beyond the unique grain patterns and cream with dark color highlights is a practical durability. Its ability to withstand everyday abuse from kids running around or pet claws scratching across floors is amazing. The high Janka rating isn’t just a fancy feature name. Its there to help you know what this floor can take! handle the rough and tumble of daily life.

        But strength without style is a muscle head without cologne. Luckily for us, Hickory isn't just about brawn, it brings beauty too. Its bright creamy heartwood blends well with the dark brown tones in the sapwood. Adding the distinct grain patterns make it an aesthetically pleasing choice that enhances any home with a rustic décor flair.

        Pros of Hickory Flooring

        Hickory flooring isn't just about aesthetics. Its true charm lies in its toughness and practicality. You might ask, why hickory? Well, imagine a dance party in your living room with zero worry about scratches or dents on the floor.

        hickory natural floors

        How Hickory Flooring Enhances Home Resale Values

        The first advantage that makes hickory stand out is its incredible durability. Known for being a durable wood species, it can handle more than just everyday wear and tear. This hardwood takes life's ups and downs like a champ – kids running around, pets playing, you name it. With this level of resilience comes less maintenance work for homeowners. But let's not forget how water-resistant hickory is. In climates that are tough on hardwood floors due to moisture or temperature fluctuations, hickory still holds strong. So no need to panic over spilled drinks during those lively family gatherings anymore. Apart from these functional benefits, there’s also an aesthetic side to consider when looking at flooring options - light colors brighten up rooms while adding warmth as well as elegance. In fact, did you know that lighter shades help spaces appear larger too?

        Bonus: Good Looking and Scratch-Resistant

        Honestly speaking, the rustic appearance of the grain patterns found in real hickory adds a unique touch to any home decor style. It beautifully balances both modern minimalism and traditional country themes. So if you're planning to sell your house down the line, having beautiful hickory floors can be a real deal-sealer. Hickory can increase home resale values and create a cozy nest for your family to enjoy. Hickory flooring offers both practicality and elegance. Not bad for some wood planks from an edible tree species, right?

        Cons of Hickory Flooring

        Although hickory floors are admired for their unique grain patterns and durability, there are a few downsides to consider. Price can be a factor to consider when choosing hickory flooring as it is typically more expensive than other hardwood options such as oak or ash. Hickory planks can be pricier than other hardwood options like oak or ash.

        hickory hardwood in a living room

        The Cost Factor in Choosing Hickory Flooring

        Hickory's exceptional hardness doesn't come without a price tag. This robust wood species often costs more than softer woods like pine or fir flooring, but it does offer longer-lasting beauty and strength. Yet, the upfront investment might make you think twice if budget is your top priority. In addition to material costs, installation isn't always easy-breezy with this tough nut either. Due to its density and complex grain pattern, hickory requires skilled hands for successful installation - making DIY projects quite challenging. The difficulty doesn’t stop at installation though; maintenance can also present challenges over time because dust and dirt tend to stand out on light-colored hickory floors – demanding regular cleaning schedules. Despite these cons, don’t write off this magnificent tree just yet. The overall benefits could outweigh the drawbacks depending on what’s most important in your quest for perfect flooring.

        Comparing Hickory Flooring to Other Wood Options

        If you're thinking about new floors, hickory might be on your list. How does hickory measure up against other hardwood varieties such as oak, ash, teak and ebony?

        hardwood flooring in a man cave

        Why Choose Hickory Over Oak or Ash?

        Hickory flooring has some distinct advantages over its competitors. One of the main selling points is its strength. It's more than 30% stronger than white oak making it a hardy choice for high-traffic areas. This toughness doesn't come at the cost of beauty either. With creamy brown tones and an interesting grain pattern, hickory offers both durability and aesthetic appeal. Hickory flooring is not as widespread as other types of genuine wood, giving your abode a distinct appearance that sets it apart from the others.

        Hickory vs Maple and Teak

        When compared with other woods like teak or hard maple floors, hickory still holds its own. While these options may offer darker hues or wider planks in their favor; they often carry higher price tags too. The balance between quality and affordability makes hickory a contender when choosing between different wood floor patterns.

        Faux Wood Floorings: A Close Contender?

        Fake wood flooring options, such as laminate or vinyl plank, are growing popular due to their lower costs but they lack authenticity.

        "Remember," says Dave Moore from ReallyCheapFloors.com "Real hardwood floors add value to homes."

          While these options may mimic the look of wood, they don't quite replicate the feel or longevity of genuine hickory. Choosing flooring can be tough with so many wood flooring types. But understanding how hickory compares to other woods and fake alternatives makes it easier. With its unique blend of strength, beauty, and affordability; Hickory just might have a slight edge.

         
        Key Thought:    When deciding on new flooring, don't overlook hickory. Its superior strength makes it perfect for high-traffic areas, and its unique grain pattern adds a touch of elegance. It's more affordable than exotic woods like teak or ebony but offers similar durability and aesthetic appeal. And unlike faux wood options, real hickory adds value to your home.

        Solid Hickory vs. Engineered Hickory

        When you're in the market for new floors, choosing between solid hickory and hickory engineered hardwood is a big decision. Let's investigate further so you can make an educated choice.

        5 ply engineered hardwood cross section photo

        The Pros and Cons of Engineered Hickory Flooring

        Engineered wood has its share of fans thanks to its flexibility in handling temperature changes. It's a good pick if your home sees big swings in humidity or temperature. This flooring type is built from several layers of plywood with a top layer made from real hardwood like Bruce Hickory Flooring. The layered design helps it resist warping that could occur with large climate shifts. But here’s the kicker: While engineered hickory does well against weather variations, it may not match up to solid hickory when we talk about longevity and wear-and-tear resistance.

        Durability Comparison Between Solid And Engineered Hickory Floors

        If durability is your prime concern, then there’s no beating solid hardwoods - especially something as sturdy as our star player today - solid hickory. Made entirely out of natural wood harvested straight off the mighty trees, these are floors designed for generations. A bonus point? With every scratch or dent over time (and let’s face it – life happens.), you can refinish the floor more often than engineered hardwood. They look brand spanking new again.

        Battle Of Costs: Which One Weighs Lighter On Your Wallet?

        In terms of cost-effectiveness though, engineered options often take center stage compared to their traditional counterparts such as pure white oak or hickory. So if you're on a tight budget but don't want to compromise on the charm of real wood under your feet, engineered flooring could be your ticket. Just remember, cost is only one part of the equation when deciding between solid and engineered hickory floors.

         
        Key Thought:  Choosing between solid and engineered hickory flooring boils down to what you value more. Solid hickory wins in durability, handling wear-and-tear like a champ with its easy-to-refinish nature. Engineered hickory shines in cost-effectiveness and flexibility under varying climates, but may fall short on longevity compared to its solid counterpart.

         

        FAQs

        What are the cons of hickory flooring?

        Hickory flooring can be more expensive than other hardwoods. It's also tough to install due to its hardness, making DIY projects challenging.

        Do hickory floors scratch easily?

        No, they don't. Thanks to their high Janka scale rating, hickory floors resist scratches better than most hardwood options.

        Does hickory flooring yellow over time?

        All wood yellows over time due to oxidation and UV exposure but with a quality finish and proper care, you can minimize this effect on your hickory floor.

        Is hickory flooring better than oak?

        In terms of strength and durability, yes. Hickory is stronger by about 30%. But keep in mind that choice depends on factors like cost, aesthetics and maintenance too.

        Conclusion

        When it comes to flooring choices, hickory stands out. Its unique grain pattern and creamy brown color make it a visual delight, but the true strength lies in its durability. Hickory is one of America's hardest woods, scoring impressively on the Janka scale. Hickory floors are water-resistant and scratch-tolerant making them ideal for high-traffic areas. But they're not just about practicality; their light colors can brighten up rooms too! While there are downsides like cost factors and installation challenges, these are balanced by benefits such as increased home resale values that come with this beautiful hardwood. In weighing up your options among oak, ash or faux wood floorings remember - none offer quite the same package as hickory does. From solid to engineered versions - each type brings something different to your space. Weighing all these hickory flooring pros and cons, you now have everything you need for an informed decision on whether this sturdy contender fits your needs perfectly or if alternatives might be better suited for you.

Related Products
Dark Handscraped Hickory Hardwood in a modern home picture
Price:
$3.99
Width:
3.25
Grade:
1st Quality
Color Name:
River Hickory
Location:
Murphy, NC
Type:
Prefinished Solid
Light Natural Hickory Hardwood Floor in a modern kitchen
Price:
$3.29
Width:
3
Grade:
Builder
Color Name:
Forest
Location:
Murphy, NC
Type:
Prefinished Solid
Dark Hickory Floor
Price:
$3.29
Width:
3
Grade:
Builder
Color Name:
Charmed
Location:
Murphy, NC
Type:
Prefinished Solid
Country Low Gloss S
Price:
$3.29 - $7.55
Width:
3.25 - 5
Grade:
Cabin, 1st Quality, Builder
Color Name:
Hickory Driftwood
Location:
Murphy, NC
Type:
Prefinished Solid