Choosing between a quality waterproof floor vs water resistant flooring is a biggie for a homeowner and flooring installer. Both options offer water protection, but choosing the wrong one can lead to a real bad day in the future. I explain the differences between waterproof and water resistant floors on this page. You will know which type of floor will work best for you after reading.
Choosing between a quality waterproof floor vs water resistant flooring is a biggie for a homeowner and flooring installer. Both options offer water protection, but choosing the wrong one can lead to a real bad day in the future. I explain the differences between waterproof and water resistant floors on this page. You will know which type of floor will work best for you after reading.
What's the Difference?
While both types of flooring offer protection against water, their level of resistance varies greatly. Pinning down the distinctions between both is trickier than it sounds. For instance, if you are looking for ideal flooring for a laundry room, you'll want something waterproof.
Water-Resistant Flooring: Limited Defense
Think of water-resistant flooring as a thin silk jacket. A silk jacket can keep you dry in a quick sprinkle of rain, but not a downpour. It can handle minor spills, splashes, and pet accidents, but only if you wipe them up quickly.
Leaving liquids to sit on the surface of a laminate floor for extended periods can seep into its wood composite core and ruin it completely. It's a good option for areas with low moisture and minimal chances of major spills, such as bedrooms or home office spaces.
Waterproof Flooring: Ultimate Protection
Unlike its water-resistant counterpart, waterproof flooring boasts an impenetrable shield against water damage. Imagine it as a fortress, engineered to withstand even the most extreme liquid encounters.
Whether it's a major spill, pet accidents, or even a flood, this flooring type is designed to prevent water from penetrating its core. Waterproof laminate floors are a popular waterproof flooring choice.
For instance, waterproof vinyl flooring is a popular option because of its ability to repel water. It is ideally suited for areas prone to high moisture levels, such as kitchens, bathrooms, mudrooms, and basements.
Yet, this doesn't mean other elements of your installation are entirely immune. Subfloors, adhesives, and other installation materials might still be vulnerable to moisture.
Not All Vinyl Is Created Equal: WPC vs SPC
Even though many consider all vinyl flooring waterproof, it's essential to pay close attention to product specifics. One specific detail to focus on is a WPC or a SPC vinyl plank floor.
WPC (Wood Plastic Composite) and SPC (Stone Plastic Composite) are both rigid vinyl floors but they are made from very different materials. WPC has a wood composite core that is soft underfoot, but less resistant to damage. In contrast, SPC has a solid vinyl core infused with plastic and limestone. An SPC feels exceptionally tough and can handle significant abuse. SPC floors are more resilient to damage and abuse than WPC floors in general.
Retail Sales Associates should communicate transparently about the performance capabilities of different products.
For example, sheet vinyl is 100% waterproof because there are no seams.
| Flooring Type | Waterproof | Water Resistant | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sheet Vinyl | Some Products | All Products | $ |
| Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) | Some Types | All Types | $$ |
| Tile | Yes | Grout is water resistant | $$$ |
But, what about Luxury Vinyl Plank? It is only sometimes considered waterproof. This is because the seams of LVP can allow water to seep through if not installed correctly. If you are considering LVP, you should familiarize yourself with water-resistant options available.
Water Resistant Doesn't Mean Impervious
While waterproof flooring boasts superior resistance against liquids, that doesn’t make it indestructible. Both types require proper installation, care, and maintenance for optimal performance and longevity.
Neglecting regular cleaning and promptly addressing spills, even on a waterproof surface, can lead to staining, subfloor mold growth, and a decrease in its overall lifespan. Think about waterproofing or water resistant flooring like a car.
You wouldn't drive your car through a flood and expect it to run perfectly afterward without any maintenance, right? The same applies to your floors. Proper care is essential to keep it looking like the marketing showrooms and photos that dealers like to point at.
Even though both floors offer some level of protection from water damage, they are still susceptible to corruption if not maintained well.
Additionally, it is important to use cleaning products specifically designed for your flooring type. Using harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners can damage the protective layer of the floor, making it more susceptible to water damage. It's like using dish soap on your hair.
FAQs about waterproof and water-resistant floors
Which is better waterproof or water-resistant?
Ultimately, the better option boils down to where you're installing it and your budget. But, if you can swing it, waterproof flooring offers greater peace of mind.
That being said, if you're working on a budget and need to install new flooring in your bedroom, water-resistant flooring will be totally fine - especially in areas that are not prone to high moisture. Just understand that you'll need to be extra cautious with spills. It all boils down to what you're willing to spend.
Is a water-resistant floor okay for a bathroom?
It really is not. Water-resistant flooring is more vulnerable to moisture damage. And let's face it: Bathrooms are constantly exposed to moisture from showers, baths, and sinks.
While a little bit of water probably won't cause too much of a problem, bigger spills and standing water are cause for concern. That's why we recommend opting for a waterproof solution.
Also, keep in mind that the subfloor is also important. In some instances, no matter what the waterproof rating, if the subfloor isn't waterproof, your flooring will still have problems if the top gets saturated and can't dry out.
Is LVP waterproof or water-resistant?
Ah, a trick question. Luxury Vinyl Plank, or LVP, depends on its specific construction. Some LVPs are designed to be fully waterproof. Others are water-resistant. Waterproof versions usually feature a completely waterproof core and a tighter locking system that prevents water from seeping through the seams.
But make sure you are reading those product descriptions before you decide. While luxury vinyl is a great option, it is essential to understand the difference between waterproof laminate vs. vinyl plank flooring to make an informed decision.
What flooring is 100% waterproof?
Several flooring options are close to being 100% waterproof. I would say tile is as close to 100% waterproof as you can get. If your budget allows, porcelain tile will stand the test of time.
Sheet vinyl is another good option. Both are great choices if you're seeking more than just basic protection from water.
Conclusion
The reasons you buy a waterproof or water-resistant floor is about your lifestyle and your budget. The materials and benefits of both options help you know what room to install them in. Each flooring choice has pros and cons as any floor type will like hardwood, carpet, or any other new floor technology that comes out. Waterproof flooring is a catch-all because it will perform great in any room.
Ultimately the decision is yours. Just be sure you have all the right information when going about your renovation. You got this.
